« two heuristics to live by | Main | Bishop Nazir Ali on Britishness and the Judeo Christian Tradtion »

whitey

No, not that one...
shark.JPG

This one: Carcharodon carcharias - the man in the grey suit

We've been having a lot of Great White Shark encounters in SoCal recently. Apparently, they're sticking around longer after giving birth and no one really knows why, but I'm sure global warming is the reason because it's the reason for everything else. Aside from the triathlete that got attacked and killed in Encinitas, some of the stories being told are pretty interesting:

On June 21, 2008 Bettina Pereira was kayaking 300 feet from shore at West Cove, Catalina Island. Her husband Andrew remained aboard their boat to fish with their children. Air and water temperatures were estimated at 80 and 67 degrees Fahrenheit respectively. It was about 9 AM with a clear sky and a calm sea surface. Pereira was paddling a 12 foot blue kayak over water 50 feet deep with 40 feet of visibility. The bottom dropped off quickly to over 500 feet just beyond her starting location. William Weilbacher was fishing from his boat, which was one of five fishing boats within several hundred yards of Pereira. He provided the following information; “I was in the process of pinning my first squid on the hook when I heard a scream from the direction of the kayak. I looked over and saw the kayak flipping over and the woman going in the water. She was about a hundred yards away. I saw a big splash next to the boat and then saw what I initially thought was an arm waving back and forth and splashing. After about two seconds I realized the 'arm' was actually part of a huge shark tail oriented vertically in the water and it was thrashing back and forth right at the surface. The large dark shape was actually part of the shark sticking out of the water. The portion of the tail I could see looked like it was three feet long. The shark was pushing on the kayak and the woman was on the far side of the kayak holding on and screaming.” Andrew Pereira said “Bettina felt a strong bump to the back of her kayak. It was so hard she thought a boat had run into her. When she turned to look behind, she saw the body of a large shark coming up underneath her kayak. It rose up so quickly that she was thrown from her seating position in the kayak to one of standing upright on her feet, which were on the back of the shark.” Weilbacher continued; “We were anchored so there was nothing we could do in time to be of any use, but there were two other small boats drift fishing. We were closer and I don't know if they couldn't see what was happening as well, or what. We started screaming at them to go help her and that there was a shark and they both went at her at full throttle. I would estimate the size of the Great White Shark to be 15 feet.” Bettina Pereira sustained some bruising but was not cut by the shark during her most shocking encounter.

and

On March 7, 2008 Thomas Larkin was surfing with two friends. He recounted the following; “I was surfing a 6’6” Avisco (carbon fiber) Surf Prescriptions Bat Tail Quad. I paddled out at Dog Beach near Huntington Cliffs around 7:10 in the morning at a pretty full high tide. Dog Beach is located in a stretch of Huntington City Beach between Seapoint Street and Golden West Street. I was meeting two friends there, Matt Donoghue and Craig Angel. The current was moving around a lot of water, and both of them were on longboards, so about 20 minutes into the surf I was tired of paddling over to them on my shortboard, and was surfing pretty much alone. There were two bodyboarders about 100 yards north of me, and I was almost due west of the ramp walkway. At about 8:00 AM, I caught my best wave of the session, and even though Matt and Craig had already gotten out, I wanted one more. I paddled back out and was sitting in the lineup alone, with the closest surfers about 200 yards south, and the bodyboarders were inside and north. I was waiting for a set for about 5 minutes when I felt a jolt down on the tail of my board, immediately followed by violent bubble cascade, which sunk the board down about another 8 inches (see photograph). I didn’t really get what was going on as quickly as I should have, but as soon as it begun it had ended and I was apparently alone again. A wave popped up, I paddled into it but pearled because of the water in the nose of my board, I quickly got back on and paddled into the whitewater of the next wave and boogie boarded it to the beach where I emptied the board through the apparent bite mark." The diameter of the bite suggests an adult White Shark in excess of 15 feet in length.

You can see the bite on the page linked above. I surf there all the time with a similar board. Oh well.

This one is by far the best:
On June 3, 2008 Scott Ball and Kyle Faust, a professional diver, were spearfishing near Carlsbad State Beach. Ball was wearing a black and grey spring suite, a black 100 cm speargun, a black mask, and a blue snorkel and long blue fins. Water temperature was estimated at 65 degrees Fahrenheit with the depth about 15 feet. The ocean floor was primarily several reefs with open sandy areas between. There was a steady breeze pushing 3 – 5 foot ground swells under a clear blue sky. It was 10:30 AM and they had been in the water about 45 minutes. Ball recounted; “I was near the bottom when I saw something huge coming at me. It was a shadow off in the distance. I surfaced to tell Kyle what I had seen. A few minutes later I dove under to find a large black eye, bigger than my fist, no more than 1 or 2 feet from me. The shark is starring at me when it makes a slow turn to swim away. It was a big shark; the teeth on it were huge and actually visible in the mouth. After a few seconds of this stare down it did almost a casual turn and swam off. The visibility was 8-10' and at one point I couldn't see the head or the tail just the massive girth and body. The top of the shark was a dark grey and the bottom was much lighter in color. When it pushed away with its tail it actually moved me a bit in the water from the force. So now I make the rookie mistake and start ‘booking it’ to shore going ‘oh s--t.’ On my way in, about 30 seconds later, I looked to my left and saw a dorsal fin, 2 – 2.5 feet high, coming directly at me. As it neared me it sank below the surface and swam directly under me. I don’t know how long it was and I’m not going to say it was as wide as a VW, but it was massive in width and length. The last time it came at me was real fast. The shark buzzed me a total of 3 times, so it was very persistent. Once on the beach I noticed a crowd so I walked over and there was a beached sea lion being harassed by 3 or 4 beachgoers. The seal was about 10 feet from the water’s edge but would not go in the water to get away from the harassment. This was a learning experience and a scary one.”
I've heard they're so large they look like submarines when you see one in the water.

You're chances of surviving a GWS attack while diving are actually pretty poor, because there's nothing between you and the shark's lower teeth. It can just clamp right down on you. If you're on a surfboard, you've only got something like a 20% chance of dying if attacked, even though the odds of getting attacked in the first place are extremely low. Really, it's a miracle more people aren't attacked given how much we use the water. I think GWSs are probably smarter than we previously thought. They're kind of like big, toothy dogs that after looking at something and smelling it, they take a test bite and decide from there whether to eat it. More often than not though, they probably just look and then swim off, like what happened (more or less) to the guy above.

Still, my friend wants to go surfing in the Channel Islands in the fall, and there are a lot of seals there so I'm probably going to use some sort of shark repellent device when I go. Medical help is simply too far away out there.

Posted on Wednesday, July 16, 2008 at 01:04PM by Registered CommenterPRCalDude | Comments6 Comments

Reader Comments (6)

Heh heh...I remember in 1975, taking my final shakedown dive for my cert card at Anacapa Island, where there are mucho seals and sea lions. About a month later, they dragged in a 17-ft. White which was caught right around that area; he was frozen, jaws opened wide, in a huge block of ice and put on display at a marine park in the Southland (don't remember which one). Very chilling and sobering, but not enough so for me to abstain from getting wet, I'm afraid.

We waterfolk are strange, are we not?

July 17, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterToa

Well, I'm not diving in Carlsbad any time soon, nor near the spot in CAtalina where it drops down real deep real quickly on the back side of the island. I was on the spearboard the other day and this guy described this GWS he saw chasing this sea lion out at this one spot in Catalina. He decided not to jump in. (Duh).

It's too bad that the best places to surf and dive are also where the great whites go. I guess we'll just have to learn to live with them. Maybe going out at those spots when the tide is going out the strongest isn't such a good idea. The dolphins always show up at the river mouths to see what gets washed out when the tide is going out. I bet other things show up as well.

I think if you're gonna dive, it's best to buy a shark shield and turn it on. I know it's paranoid, but I just prefer not worrying about it. I've dove Palos Verdes at night for lobster and I don't think that's such a good idea anymore.

July 18, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterPRCalDude

Do you ever free dive, Toa?

July 18, 2008 | Registered CommenterPRCalDude

Cal, I think the last time I free-dove was right south of La Bufadora in Baja around 1976 or'77. All-rock cove/beach, accessable only by hiking down, at least 80 foot viz...HOOHAH!!!! Most of my jumping has been on compressed air, either SCUBA or surface-supplied (that's where my chosen handle "Toa" comes from- Toa Sensuiki Kaisha of Tokyo, makers of one of the most comfortable helmets in the world). Haven't made a dive in some time though; the last few years have been almost solely boat dives at the Islands off the "Spectre" out of Ventura. Obtained a compound fracture in my right forearm in March, which by our Lord's mercy I am mending from now, so it's been "dry" for the time being.

Nothing paranoid about using repellents in my view, no matter where you're diving. I've heard from various sources that Whites are not prone to hang out in shallow kelp forests, but if an animal is hungry enough, I'm sure he would bend whatever rules he is supposed to live by.

Palos Verdes is good diving...only jumped it one day, for our final exam in commercial SCUBA applications under U.S. Divers' Tommy Thompson at Commercial Diving Center (now College of Oceaneering). From what I can gather from this blog, you live around there somewhere. What about you, still get wet? Sorry to run on so long, but that's what happens when divers converge...mucho hot air!!!!

July 18, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterToa

I've dove PV about 3 times - Lundada bay once. We saw a bunch of halibut but none worth shooting (they're damn hard to see on the bottom, even with good vis.) I've gone bugging on the north side of PV a couple of times, all the while thinking there were hardly any GWS in SoCal. From what I've been reading this isn't such a good idea anymore. I'm looking for a Euro speargun about 70" long and then I'll probably start diving it again. Malibu is good also. Someone took a 90 lb white sea bass up there about a year ago.

Re: the whites in shallow forests: PV has some, but GWSs are known to feed there. The rule I follow is that if it's a good place to fish, it's a good place for sharks.

July 19, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterPRCalDude

Yeah, the story of the diver that had the shark swim under him was fantastic .. I'm almost surprised he didn't to into shock! Here's more good shark attack stories.

September 11, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterJeremy

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>